vgar  09/15/04 @056

Welcome back Bougal, Wow, this is fantastic work! Great concept and it is obvious you but a lot of work into this. The texture of the planet surface is amazingly detailed. My only gripes would be that the clouds in the top left corner look a little flat in comparison to the detail of the planet surface. I think also that the shockwaves look a little too smooth and look a little more "painted" or cartoony look than the rest of the pretty much photorealistic piece. Do you know what I mean? These are just minor details though. Overall I think this is a fantastic piece of work and better than the average space scene. Very well done!

Prasa  09/15/04 @074

uh ... monumental

ThruMyEyez  09/15/04 @079

Great details! Nice work!

Mini  09/15/04 @084

nice work...but..the rounding thing that shows when that planet...or meteorit...i don't know...hit the world looks not soo realistic... nice work anyway!

Spiffy  09/15/04 @099

This is soooo good! Wow, that would be really scary if that really happened! Hehe, anyway, this is really good! Love it! +7/7!!

ARTOONATOR  09/15/04 @217

The impact-tention is great! Well done!+8

mrhollow  09/15/04 @427

Really nice, I love the concept and delivery.

Dax  09/15/04 @454

Wonderful! Great work!!!

Ikaa  09/15/04 @664

Very nice!

PJClapp  09/18/04 @516

there is something about space peices that i love. youve handleed the subject matter exellently. the warm and cool tones youve used really push and pull each other. one thing that bothers my eye a bit is the composition. i would realy like to see around the big planet. i realize you were most likely trying to show a close up of the collision but by attacting the planet to the corner you loss the free standing weight that you have with the other planet and moon. great working looking forward to more. - matt

Kalininskiy  09/21/04 @821

Super!

amongfaeries  09/24/04 @578

i love the detail. it looks realistic. the soft glow of earth's atmosphere and the colours, clouds, continents. you did a really good job. but my eyes keep wandering to the moon and down further. but then it ends! good job

Findecano  09/27/04 @058

Great colours and especially the lighting, nearly perfect! +9!

TeemuR  09/27/04 @726

Love this one! Dramatic contrast and very good level of details. The compostion is also pleasing. Maybe slight blueish glow on the biggest planet could create even more atmosphere to your great image? Btw.You seem to like Greg Martin's works?

Bougal  09/27/04 @807

I do like Greg Martin's works. Of course, I would never try to copy them; I try to be unique.

illustmaster  09/27/04 @887

Oh great! Two planets are loving each other.

tomkoff  09/28/04 @513

the end is near ;D +6/7

Andy--Jones  09/29/04 @646

This is amazing and you have so much more patience than i do. Everything is perfect so i will try and find fault...maybe a few more stars! +8

Padawan  09/30/04 @256

I love the surface and its details. However the the clouds dont seem to fit into the composition, they dont have the same amount of detail and they look flat. Also, the smaller moon is too close to the planet, there is something called the "Roche's sphere" which means that if a moon is too close to the planet, it will be ripped apart by gravitational forces. Finally, i would add some cracks on the surface of the planet too. The star field is well done, 5/7

katep  10/16/04 @016

nice work! +7 / 7 !

reilanchan  10/20/04 @967

Wow! To me it looks absolutely awesome; the detail is great! (You may already know that i love space art *fg*) +9 ^_^

NEONPOX  10/28/04 @354

First off the lighting is off, the moon would be... no I'm just messing around with you. looks great +7

Jane  10/29/04 @374

Amazing! +9/9

robertmekis  11/12/04 @841

How it's possible I have overlooked this !?

ReinMan  11/22/04 @677

Brilliant work! (thank heavens you critiqued me or I would have missed this! )

Sven  11/25/04 @915

Cant say anything!!! +10

jamesjr  12/01/04 @902

Loving the detail this is great stuff! keep it up!

Rjrickett  12/02/04 @371

nice work very origonal and a great improvment to your earlier stuff i couldnt even tell its a digital image

Angeloonie  12/02/04 @982

I love this piece, it's awesome, but the few things I don't really like is that the clouds at the top part are a bit too... too white, they're too compact, lacking a bit of flowing edges if you get what I mean. Also the impact is a bit too round for my liking, it looks awesome, but not realistic in my eyes. Should've been a bit more blurred/dusty. But, like I said, I love this part, the debris looks awesome, the planet textures are incredible, and your stars look really nice 7/7

SailorDidi  12/05/04 @033

+9, its gorgeous

Ov3RMinD  12/14/04 @928

The planettexture of the big planet is very realistic and beautiful, but the clouds dont fit to the ground surface of the planet. They look a bit more spherized than the ground surface. And on the medium large planet the shadow side of the planet is too dark. I think when the large planet is that bright on this side, the smaller planet should be much brighter. Although, nice composition. +5/7

Pahaliah  12/23/04 @419

This image shows how insignificant we are in the universe. This artwork its simply wonderful. +10

Wormwood  01/05/05 @122

A series of impacts/collisions like this would be so great.

Cinnamon  01/14/05 @874

Wow - the details are incredible

Cinnamon  01/14/05 @874

Wow - the details are incredible

Wendl  01/15/05 @196

waw.....no words to say...

Inabottle  01/17/05 @852

I didnt comment on this I could have sworn I did!! this is marvelous... lovely detail... and color +10

Arthony  01/17/05 @867

the clouds are good, but not good enough to match the incredible detail displayed all thruoghout. A fantastic liking. very dynamic. great composition. I personaly like the waves of collition

MsMichelleLynn  01/24/05 @511

This is fantastic! I am an astronomy buff so I appreciate this type of work. You also have a great imagination. Great job! 9/10

Miss-Psycho  02/03/05 @637

upss.... Strong. You´ve a very creative style. Well done.

Xris  03/02/05 @876

wow..... ? 9/9 no crits

Bellerophon  03/10/05 @902

W O W !!! I really like space images expecialy http://sirgerg.gfxartist.com 's You are next GREG MARTIN... beileve me... Keep going +10/10 Sorry because I can't give you more that +5 in my 'Cast your vote' I haven't that option...

eremita  03/23/05 @830

Almost-Human  03/26/05 @752

Its already been said. Great image...

bloknayrb  06/08/05 @658

very nice job, my only grips is that the lightsource on the small collision planet is partially incorrect... isnt there also a lightsource behind it, the same one that is lighting the other planets?

Madanapale  07/24/05 @380

Amazing Work!!!....top marks Carlos

TheNeverman  10/25/06 @713

simply gorgeous... the land mass textures - all from scratch?